SirMax's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Castle Repercussions - A]

10/10

Jag har aldrig i hela mitt liv stött på någon svensk som är så bra på att animera som du. Dehär är helt sjukt. Man skulle nästan kunna jämföra detta med Adam Phillips. Roligt att det finns människor I Sverige med talang för animation. Jag trodde jag var den ända intresserade.

Ljuset, skuggorna och bakgrunderna var väldigt professionellt gjorda. Själva animationen var helt underbar. Men om det finns något som du kanske kan bättra på tills nästa gång så kan det vara en bättre story. För jag förstår inte riktigt meningen med den och det är svårt för de som aldrig sett serien innan.
Allt annat var helt perfekt. Jag ger dig en 10:a för en sådan mirakulös film

TRANSLATION:

I have never in my life met a Swede who is so good at animating as you. This is completely sick. One might compare this to Adam Phillips. Funny that there are people in Sweden with a talent for animation. I thought I was alone.

The light, shadows and backgrounds were very professional. The actual animation was wonderful. But if there is anything that you may be able to improve until the next time it may be a better story. Because I do not really understand the point of it, and it is difficult for those who never seen the series before.
Everything else was perfect. I give you a 10 for such a miraculous film

Get-lost responds:

Tackar

[Daydreams.]

8/10

Va roligt att det finns fler svenskar än jag som gillar att animera. Du har skillz och är väldigt säker i ditt arbete. I like it :)

MarcyVF responds:

Takk, SirMax. Jeg och Tommy är inte svenska, vi er norske :) Men SimonG har svensk familie. Kanskje du så 'Simon's weird swedish chair' bak på stolen i begynnelsen? :P

[Professor Layton pt. 4]

9/10

This is funny as hell. I was laughing hystericly.

It seems like you guys had a good time when you made this. And you didn't use a script, am I right? Well, you don't need one for this kind of animations.
The characters and background where drawn pretty fucked up. But it was a good fit with the style. I like how you express the feelings, especially the aggression.
It all connected with each other and that's the point. Good job!

Skaijo responds:

I appreciate the indepth review and the love. There wasn't much of a script as there was just a simple idea and a few catchphrases I wanted included in the audio. Then my friends and I just spent the time feeding lines to TW, and after the audio was mixed, I got something funny to animate too. Simple graphics for a simple idea--and bam! Done without much sweat.

[Watchmen trailer]

8/10

It cracked me up so bad!

[The Woes of Marsh]

9/10

I like you animation style and how you executed the movie. The plot was really well written, and you got a relief feeling at the end that the whole thing was a faint or something. The only down side is that the lines where pretty bad. So I suggest you get a wacom tablet. Maybe it contributed to the style, what do I know? Great job and I hope you continue this.

[The Final Act]

9/10

Great! I hope you got an A.

It is really cool of how much expressions you could get from
no words. The animation was really good, I think you should
take that a step further because you got some talent. And for
next time try to make som awesome backgrounds too. That
helps alot. Keep them coming! :D

orb responds:

Thanks! Yeah I'm working with two friends of mine on a longer, much more complex animation that should be out around June.

[Girlchan in Paradise Ep1]

6/10

First I thougt: Wow. Egotaptor actually made a good shot for his own anime show. All started of REALLY well. And there wasn't a single problem. But then I noticed that along the way it began to be more of a parody.
All the sarcasm. The bad lip syncing, the exaggerated voices and all the fighting scenes. Yeah, you pretty much screwed up.

Egoraptor responds:

...what?

[A little walk]

2/10

You didn't do anythingof the animation. You took a finished walk cycle and copied the motions. And the background was kinda bad. I give you a low score because of the copying.